How to Define and Demonstrate ISO Management System Processes – Part 2 Internal Auditing Basics

Examples for understanding management system processes.

Defining ISO management system processes and understanding the process approach 

In our previous blog, we discussed how an audit of management system requirements should be done by auditing the organization’s processes, and through them, the interactions with the management system standard’s requirements (this is known as the “process approach” to auditing).  What is meant by the term process?  In ISO 9001, a process is defined as a “set of interrelated or interacting activities that use inputs to deliver an intended result.”  However, according to ISO 9001 clause 4.4.1, the organization must determine the processes required for its management system.  These are the organization’s defined processes to which all of the requirements of clause 4.4.1 will apply.  While ISO 9001 may refer to the “internal audit process,” internal auditing is only a management system process if defined as such by the organization.  There are many processes within a management system, but it is up to the organization to determine how these processes are defined.

The “process approach” is a core quality management principle, requiring organizations to systematically define, manage, and coordinate processes to achieve results aligned with their quality policy and strategic goals. While there is no right or wrong way to decide what should be a management system process and what should be an activity within a larger process; a balance is needed between having too many processes (and being overwhelmed by the overhead of managing them), or having too few processes (causing a lack of focus and oversight).  For most systems, less than ten processes seem to be optimal for achieving that balance. 

Knowledge. Expertise. Experience.

Outsource Your Internal Audits

Consulting Services For ISO, IATF, AS, and more

Once the organization determines the management system processes, then the auditor must audit those defined processes, and through them, the relevant management system standards. One useful tool to determine the applicable standards is something called a process-clause matrix that shows which standard requirements are linked with which quality management system (QMS) processes, and to this you can add how they are addressed. In this example, an “X” denotes a direct requirement from the clause associated with the process – an “O” denotes a potential or secondary impact from the clause to the associated process.

Process clause matrix

Regardless of how the organizations choose to define their management system processes, the processes defined must meet the hard ”shall” requirements in clause 4.4.1, which are auditable and should be the starting point for auditing each process (the next blog – Part 3 of the series – will expand on the common QMS requirements that can be audited for all QMS processes). 

Every QMS process must consist of the following components:

  • A process owner who has the responsibility and authority to manage the QMS process and its outputs (see ISO 9001 clause 4.4.1 e and 5.3 b, and IATF 16949 clause 5.1.1.2).
  • The inputs required for the process (and perhaps their supplier(s)) and outputs expected (and their receivers or customer(s)). Refer to ISO 9001 clause 4.4.1 a.
  • The performance indicators that tell us whether the process is effective (and also efficient for product realization processes), and in general, how the process will be controlled. Refer to ISO 9001 clause 4.4.1 c.
  • What kind of resources are needed for the effective operation of the process? These resources can include people, equipment, materials, information, computer systems, and more. See ISO 9001 clause 4.4.1 d.
  • The risks and opportunities associated with the process and actions related to those prioritized, as well as any corrective actions or changes needed to ensure that the QMS process achieves its intended results.

A common way to depict a QMS process is by using a Turtle Diagram (see simpleQuE’s Resource Center for free examples to download):

Turtle diagram

Other methods include the 4M (or 6M) diagrams, or “SIPOC”, or simply a table:

Examples of 4 or 6 M and SIPOC

To show the sequence and interactions of all of the defined QMS processes (required by ISO 9001 clause 4.4.1 b)), a “Process Map” is typically used:

Process flow diagram

In summary

While none of the preceding examples are required, some type of method is needed to define each QMS process and the overall sequence and interaction to effectively describe how the organization defines the QMS processes it has determined to be necessary.  The next blog will explain how to audit these Quality Management System (QMS) processes.

This is Part 2 of the 4-part Internal Auditing Basics series, which was created for first-time auditors or anyone wanting to brush up on their auditing skills. Part 1 addressed the topic of “ISO Management System Audit Criteria and Their Hierarchy”. Part 3 examines “Common QMS Requirements for all processes”.  The series wraps up with Part 4 – “How to write an audit finding”. These helpful tips are also taught in simpleQuE training courses for internal auditors, where trainees have the opportunity to do process auditing exercises, including a practice audit that is customized to their company’s processes.

This article was written by Paul Gambino, a simpleQuE consultant, trainer and auditor with more than 20 years’ experience implementing, maintaining and improving quality management systems and business processes. He has also conducted ISO 9001 and IATF 16949® audits for several Certification Bodies. 

SimpleQuE is a leader in AS, IATF® and ISO consulting, auditing and training.  Whether you are just beginning the certification process or looking for a partner for ongoing maintenance and internal audits, simpleQuE makes the process easier and more efficient. Contact us for a consult and see the difference that simpleQuE can bring to your quality management process.

Learn More About The simpleQuE Advantage

The simpleQuE Advantage Begins Here! Contact Us Today