The Good, Bad and Ugly of Contingency Planning Within IATF 16949®

IATF 16949® Contingency Planning – Best Practices VS Bad Practice

For IATF 16949® certified automotive suppliers, a contingency plan is the defined tool to prepare for emergencies, issues and disasters to ensure that customer specifications and requirements will continue to be met.  

Contingency planning is represented in IATF 16949® under Section 6.1.2.3, and also in Sanctioned Interpretations 3 and 17.  Not meeting these requirements is in the top of IATF 16949:2016 major and minor nonconformances. The short video clip above shares the best practices to keep you on the good side of an audit.  View the entire video as Bob Dornhecker, IATF 16949® automotive expert, consultant, and former Certification Body Auditor goes over the “Good, Bad & Ugly” of Contingency Planning that will give insight into meeting these requirements in preparation for an IATF 16949® internal audit.

Keep in mind that contingency planning is not intended to be a prevention method.  The intention is ensuring the customer receives their parts when the stuff has hit the fan. Types of “stuff hitting the fan” includes all potential issues described in 6.1.2.3 c and SI 3:  cyber security, pandemics, IT and infrastructure, natural disasters, labor shortages, etc.  Mentions of contingency planning can also occur in Customer Specific Requirements (CSRs).

Contingency plans include annual reviews by a multidisciplinary team, periodic testing and simulation of all contingencies (and record of test status), training of all necessary staff of the contingencies, and customer approval of alternative manufacturing and abnormal restart processes applied.

Contingency Planning Best Practices

  • A disaster recovery plan that focuses on actions and plans for each contingency.
  • Conducting real world simulations to ensure customer impact is minimized.
  • Individual disaster recovery focused team meetings to review and consider new risks.
  • IT testing to ensure ability to isolate and restart

Contingency Planning – Areas to Avoid

  • Assuming the plan is one person’s responsibility
  • Tests not being conducted (treating it as just a desktop exercise)
  • Employees aren’t even aware of the contingencies
  • IT plan if attacked is “hope and pray” the system still works
  • Having an alternative manufacturing site without customer acceptance or awareness

Certification Body (CB) Hot Buttons

What CB auditors don’t like to see:

  • When a contingency plan is more of a risk management plan (i.e.: fire drills are not contingency planning)
  • Process owners are not aware of plan and did not participate in developing the plan.
  • Actual disaster occurred recently and plan was not followed or updated with lessons learned
  • Test/simulations are weak and there is no evidence the simulation was conducted.

What I have seen as a CB auditor

Bob breaks it down into the “Good, Bad and Ugly” of contingency planning.

Good – A component supplier that had a well-defined contingency plan that every member of the leadership team had a hand in developing.  The site referred to the plan as their disaster recovery bible and had all the information needed to manage most disasters.  The plan was tested and had solid evidence to show the simulations worked, although the weak areas were targeted for improvement.

Bad – An injection molding company whose whole contingency plan was all prevention.  There was nothing in the plan for when a disaster strikes. I had discussions stating, although prevention is critical and part of the standard, contingency planning is required for when the disaster event already occurs.  Major nonconformance identified

Ugly – Plan was a one-page table with the same contingency – get back to running as soon as possible.  No plan, no details, no methods, no testing….nothing. Major nonconformance identified

This insight is provided by former simpleQuE consultant and auditor, Bob Dornhecker.  With over 35 years of combined experience in auditing, manufacturing and certification, Bob has an extensive automotive quality background.  Additionally, he has taught and facilitated many quality related training classes for clients and has provided support to companies securing their own ISO/Quality Management Systems certifications.  He also conducts ISO 9001 and IATF 16949® 2nd and 3rd party audits.

If you’re searching for a consultant, our team at simpleQuE is well positioned to support your IATF 16949® certification, maintenance, and internal auditing needs. SimpleQuE also offers a full line-up of IATF 16949® training courses which includes AIAG Core Tools (including the new APQP 3rd Edition and Control Plan 1st Edition), Root Cause Analysis and Problem Solving, Requirements and Implementation.  Contact us to learn more about the customized services offered to match your certification and training needs.

SimpleQuE offers a whole video series to address the top IATF 16949® major and minor nonconformances found during CB audits. You will see topics that cover:  Customer Specific Requirements, Contingency Planning, Special Characteristics, Manufacturing Process Design Outputs, Control Plans, Measurement System Analysis, Standardized Work Instructions, Customer Satisfaction, Total Productive Maintenance, Nonconformity, Corrective Action and Problem Solving. You’ll find the videos on simpleQuE’s YouTube channel . IATF 16949® Audits – The Good, Bad & Ugly

SimpleQuE is not associated with the IATF®, IAOB, ANAB®, IAQG®, and is not a certification body. SimpleQuE is an independent consulting, training, and second-party auditing service provider that assists a company on a path to obtain and maintain certification through accredited certification bodies.

 

Learn More About The simpleQuE Advantage

The simpleQuE Advantage Begins Here! Contact Us Today